Mental health remains the least comfortable topic for employees to discuss at work, despite growing awareness around well-being. New data shows that while most employees feel able to talk about personal identity and physical health, mental health still lags behind, with just 61% saying they feel comfortable sharing it in the workplace.
At the same time, workplace pressures are taking a measurable toll. More than one in three employees say their mental health has suffered due to work demands, yet only a small fraction speak up. Manhattan Mental Health Counseling says this gap reflects a deeper issue, where visibility of struggle does not translate into psychological safety, leaving many employees to cope in silence.
Mental health is still the hardest topic to share at work
Employees report higher comfort levels discussing nearly every other aspect of their identity compared to mental health, highlighting the persistence of stigma in professional environments.
- 87% feel comfortable discussing their race, ethnicity, or country of origin.
- 85% feel comfortable discussing their gender identity.
- 78% feel comfortable discussing their sexual orientation.
- 75% feel comfortable discussing their physical health.
- 71% feel comfortable discussing their religion or spirituality.
- Just 61% feel comfortable discussing their mental health.
What’s driving workplace stress behind the silence
The same data showing high levels of burnout and overwhelm also points to the underlying pressures driving workplace stress. These challenges are not isolated incidents but recurring patterns affecting a large share of employees.
- Chronic burnout from sustained job demands: With over half of employees reporting burnout, prolonged workloads, and limited recovery time are creating ongoing emotional and physical exhaustion.
- Overwhelm that disrupts daily functioning: Nearly four in 10 employees say they felt so overwhelmed it made it difficult to do their job, highlighting how stress is directly impairing performance.
- Work demands negatively impacting mental health: More than a third report that their job has actively harmed their mental well-being, showing that stress is not just external but embedded in the work itself.
- Declining productivity linked to mental strain: Over a third of employees say their mental health has reduced their ability to perform effectively, reinforcing the connection between well-being and output.
- Retention risks driven by sustained pressure: More than a quarter have considered quitting due to work-related mental health impacts, and a smaller but significant group has already left their jobs for this reason.
Why employees stay silent about mental health at work
- Fear of judgment: The stigma surrounding mental health remains the biggest barrier to speaking up, with 41% of employees saying they worry they will be judged if they disclose their struggles.
- A culture of silence: When no one else talks openly about mental health, employees are less likely to feel safe doing so themselves. Nearly 39% say the absence of these conversations keeps them quiet.
- Not wanting to appear weak: Many employees worry that admitting they are struggling will make them seem less capable or resilient. One-third (33%) say this fear prevents them from opening up.
- Concerns about career consequences: Employees often believe that disclosing mental health struggles could limit future opportunities, affect promotions, or lead to retaliation. Around 23% cite this directly, while 41% say they worry their career would be negatively impacted overall.
- The workplace itself is part of the problem: For 22% of employees, the job is one of the main causes of their mental health struggles, making it even harder to speak honestly to the people or systems contributing to the issue.
- Pressure from competitive work cultures: In highly ambitious or cutthroat environments, employees may feel there is no room to show vulnerability. While only 8% cite this as their main reason, these cultures can reinforce silence across an entire organization.
“Mental health remains one of the last true taboos in the workplace because it is still closely tied to perceptions of competence. Unlike other personal topics, disclosing a mental health struggle can be interpreted, fairly or not, as a sign that someone cannot handle their workload or perform consistently. That association makes the risk feel professional rather than personal, which is why so many employees choose to stay silent even when they are clearly struggling,” said Steven Buchwald, a mental health expert from Manhattan Mental Health Counseling.
“What stands out in the data is not just how many people are experiencing burnout or overwhelm, but how few feel safe enough to say anything about it,” he continues. “When only a small percentage of employees speak to their manager despite widespread distress, it points to a breakdown in trust. Employees are making a calculated decision that the potential consequences of speaking up outweigh the benefits, even in organizations that promote mental health resources.
“Closing that gap requires more than policies or programs,” Buchwald adds. “It depends on whether leaders actively create an environment where honesty is not penalized. When senior leadership models realistic workloads, acknowledges stress openly, and responds to vulnerability with support rather than judgment, it changes what employees believe is safe. Without that, mental health will continue to be something people manage quietly rather than something workplaces meaningfully address.”
Rebuilding trust around mental health in the workplace
- Lead by example at the top: When senior leaders openly acknowledge stress and set realistic boundaries, it shows that mental health is not a liability.
- Equip managers to respond effectively: Training managers to handle conversations with empathy and discretion helps employees feel safer speaking up.
- Align workloads with expectations: Reducing chronic overwork and setting achievable goals can prevent burnout before it escalates.
- Normalize mental health conversations: Creating regular, low-stakes opportunities to discuss well-being helps break the culture of silence.
- Ensure confidentiality and accessibility of support: Employees are more likely to use mental health resources when they trust that their privacy is protected.
- Treat mental health like physical health: Encouraging time off and support without stigma reinforces that well-being is a legitimate priority.
Photo credit: Mohamed_hassan/Pixabay
Thanks for reading CPA Practice Advisor!
Subscribe Already registered? Log In
Need more information? Read the FAQs
