A nonprofit school can be recognized as a public charity before it enrolls a single student. School status under I.R.C. sections 509(a)(1) and 170(b)(1)(A)(ii) turns on the character of the educational program the organization plans to run, not on a track record of public donations, so an organization with concrete plans can obtain a favorable determination while it is still pre-operational.
Summary:
- Pre-Operational Public Charity Status: Non-profit schools can secure public charity status under I.R.C. sections 509(a)(1) and 170(b)(1)(A)(ii) before enrolling students, as qualification relies on program structure rather than public donation history.
- Institutional Exemption Standard: Unlike most public charities, schools avoid private foundation status through their core functions—requiring a regular faculty, curriculum, student body, and location—without ever needing to meet public support financial tests.
- IRS Review & Reclassification: The IRS will not unilaterally reclassify a school’s status; if it disagrees with a requested classification, it notifies the applicant, offers an alternative, and preserves formal appeal rights if the applicant resists.
- Mandatory Nondiscrimination Policy: Private schools face a unique requirement: they must formally adopt, publicize, and operationally maintain a racially nondiscriminatory policy regarding students to obtain and preserve tax-exempt status.
And if the reviewer reads the file differently and thinks another classification fits, the IRS generally will not switch the classification quietly. In the school context it will contact the applicant, explain its view, and give the applicant a chance to agree or to defend the requested status, with formal appeal rights preserved if the applicant holds its ground.
That is the reassuring headline for advisors preparing a Form 1023 for a school that has a start date on the calendar but no classrooms in use yet. The details are worth understanding, because school status is one of the few public charity classifications that does not depend on the public support math, and because the reclassification process carries a few school-specific features that can catch a preparer off guard.
Why a school is a different kind of public charity
Every organization recognized under section 501(c)(3) is presumed to be a private foundation unless it fits one of the public charity exceptions in section 509(a). See I.R.C. section 508(b); Treas. Reg. section 1.508-1(b). Most public charities earn their status by demonstrating broad financial support. The publicly supported organization under section 170(b)(1)(A)(vi) and the gross receipts organization under section 509(a)(2) each run a fraction that measures support from the public against total support. Schools sit in a different group. They are institutional public charities, alongside churches and hospitals, that qualify because of what they are and what they do rather than because of where their money comes from. A school does not have to establish broad public support to avoid private foundation status. And this “public support” issue for these organizations is indefinitely – not just for the first five years of activity.
Under Treas. Reg. section 1.170A-9(c)(1), an educational organization qualifies as a school if its primary function is the presentation of formal instruction, it normally maintains a regular faculty and curriculum, and it normally has a regularly enrolled body of pupils or students in attendance at the place where its educational activities are regularly carried on. The category is broad, as it reaches primary, secondary, and preparatory schools, colleges and universities, and trade or professional schools. Instruction does not have to happen in a traditional classroom, and grades and formal examinations are not required. For example, the IRS has treated a martial arts studio with a scheduled curriculum and an enrolled student body as a school, and has recognized a 26-day outdoor survival course taught by full-time instructors. The common requirement is that formal instruction is the primary activity and that the faculty, curriculum, student body, and place are real and regular.
That said, this question is fact-intensive and the IRS has come out on opposite sides on situations that appear similar. For example, the IRS has found that an organization that offers a collection of lectures, workshops, and short courses on philosophies and psychic phenomena, led by “noted personalities” was not considered tax-exempt.
What happens if the IRS disagrees with your classification
Here the answer is more nuanced than a simple yes or no on whether the IRS reclassifies on its own, and it is mostly favorable to applicants. The Internal Revenue Manual instructs determination specialists to grant the best classification for which an organization qualifies, weighing its primary purpose, its sources of support, and the classification it requested. Three paths follow.
One, if the applicant qualifies for a more favorable classification and no additional information is needed, the IRS may grant that classification without contacting the applicant. Two, if the requested classification does not fit but another appears appropriate, the IRS generally contacts the applicant and allows it to accept the alternative or provide further support for its original request. Three, if the applicant does not qualify for the requested classification and rejects the alternative, the IRS proceeds through the formal adverse-determination process, with written notice and protest and appeal rights preserved.
The nondiscrimination requirement schools cannot overlook
One substantive condition applies to private schools and to no other class of public charity, and it is the item most likely to delay a school application. To qualify and remain exempt, a private school must adopt a racially nondiscriminatory policy as to students, publicize it, and operate consistently with it. The policy must appear in the governing documents and be communicated to all segments of the community the school serves, and the school bears the burden of showing it operates in a bona fide manner consistent with the policy.
Practical takeaways
For a school that has planned carefully but not yet opened, the classification path is favorable and generally predictable. Pre-operational status is not a weakness in this setting, as the school test was written to be satisfied by a regular program, and a detailed plan describes exactly that. Expect the IRS to engage rather than to reclassify by default, understand that any move off school status needs the client’s written sign off, and know that a genuine disagreement preserves the organization’s appeal and declaratory judgment rights.
Finally, get the racial nondiscrimination policy adopted, published on the homepage in the exact manner the guidance requires, and calendared for the annual Form 5578, so that the one school-specific trap is closed before the IRS ever raises it.
==
Jake A. Leahy is a tax attorney at Airdo Werwas, LLC in Chicago. He holds an LL.M. in Taxation from the Georgetown University Law Center and a J.D. from the University of Illinois Chicago School of Law. He represents closely-held businesses, local governments, and exempt organizations.
Sign in to get access to this free resource, and all of our whitepapers and reports.
Download this content today!
Register Now Already registered? Click here to Log In
Tags: Form 990, Income Taxes, IRS, nonprofits, schools, schools and taxes, Taxes
