Last month, a client brought me a letter from the Small Business Administration. The S corporation made distributions to the client in 2023 and 2024 to pay tax related to the company’s income. The SBA said those distributions violated his COVID Economic Injury Disaster Loan agreement, treated the loan as being in default, and asked for a paydown. His CPA had set up the S election. Nobody had read the loan documents.
I have reviewed a number of these SBA loan agreements for loans ranging from $19,000 to over $900,000, including the 2020 originals and the loan amendments issued in connection with 2021 and 2022 increases. The forms changed slightly over the years, but the two sentences that matter here read the same in every version I have reviewed, and they affect both entity conversions and the distributions that follow.
The clauses
The first is in the Note, in the list of events of default. The borrower is in default if it “reorganizes, merges, consolidates, or otherwise changes ownership or business structure without SBA’s prior written consent.”
The second is in the Loan Authorization and Agreement, under the heading “Limits on Distribution of Assets”:
“Borrower will not, without the prior written consent of SBA, make any distribution of Borrower’s assets, or give any preferential treatment, make any advance, directly or indirectly, by way of loan, gift, bonus, or otherwise, to any owner or partner or any of its employees, or to any company directly or indirectly controlling or affiliated with or controlled by Borrower, or any other company.”
The clause is not limited to loan proceeds, as it covers any distribution of the borrower’s assets, and the paragraph above the signature line binds the borrower to that clause “during the term of this Loan” (30 years). There are no exceptions for tax distributions, net income distributions, or a shareholder loan, which is an “advance” on its face. Wages are different: the clause does not mention compensation, and the EIDL regulation expressly permits it, as discussed next.
Two different rules, and the SBA’s own interpretation of one of them
The distribution covenant is often confused with a separate rule that answers a different question. The regulation governing EIDL proceeds, 13 CFR 123.303(b)(5), says the loan itself may not be used to “pay dividends or other disbursements to owners, partners, officers or stockholders, except for reasonable remuneration directly related to their performance of services for the business.” That rule is about what the loan money can be used for.
Tax law runs the other direction on the same facts, and that is what makes this interesting. The IRS’s position is that an S corporation must pay a shareholder who works in the business reasonable compensation for services before it makes distributions, and courts have recharacterized distributions as wages where the owner was underpaid; Watson v. United States, 668 F.3d 1008 (8th Cir. 2012), is the case most of us cite. So, a properly characterized S corporation distribution is an amount paid on the shareholder’s ownership interest, not reasonable compensation. If the distributions are traceable to the EIDL funds, they are prohibited under the regulations. The only room left is for distributions of profit the business earned on its own, and that is where the covenant takes over.
The broader question is: can the business distribute ordinary profits earned independently of the loan while the loan is outstanding?
On its face, the agreement seems to answer no, not without consent. In the past, the SBA said the covenant did not bar normal course distributions. When borrowers wrote in during 2020 and 2021 to ask if distributions were allowed, SBA personnel answered in writing that the Limits on Distribution of Assets provision “does not apply to any distribution of assets made in the normal course of business, including distributions to cover tax obligations, or distributions of net income in accordance with the bylaws or operating agreement of the company.”
As with IRS guidance, we must be careful about what that response was. It was not a regulation, and it was not in the loan documents. I looked for it in the disaster loan SOP and the published FAQs and couldn’t find it. It is an administrative reading from the agency’s servicing personnel, in an email, and the terms were conditional: normal course, tax obligations, net income, and in accordance with the governing documents. A distribution that exceeds net income, a distribution in the first year traceable to loan proceeds, a shareholder loan, or a distribution the operating agreement does not provide for falls outside that reading on its face. And a letter on my desk shows the SBA servicing center, reading a tax return, does not start from that communicated interpretation.
The question that naturally results from this fact pattern is one that nobody can answer: tax law says an S corporation distribution is not compensation. So, is it an ordinary course distribution that the SBA meant to leave alone? You can argue it both ways.
The SBA’s written informal guidance is the borrower’s best answer, and it is a good one. Just remember: the borrower must make this argument with documents in hand, because nothing in the loan agreement itself protects the distribution.
How the client got to S status matters
A straight election, where an existing LLC files Form 2553, is the easiest path. I have not found published SBA guidance treating a bare federal election, without a state law entity change, as itself a default, and I have not seen it in my own files either. The election does not itself trigger a default, but it creates a recurring compliance issue that the client’s tax return will document every year.
The statutory conversion many use raises issues. Converting the LLC to a corporation under state law changes the entity form. The Security Agreement requires advance notice, and the Note requires the SBA’s consent.
What to do now
For existing clients, pull the 1120-S returns for every EIDL borrower since the election, and review Schedule K distributions and Schedule L loans to shareholders. The loan authorization authorizes the SBA to obtain tax records, and the application included a Form 4506-T consent, so those returns can give the SBA a roadmap to distributions and shareholder transactions.
While you are in the file, read the operating agreement or bylaws. The SBA’s informal interpretation protects distributions of net income made “in accordance with” those documents, so an LLC whose operating agreement is silent as to tax distributions should amend the agreement now, prospectively, to provide for them. Keep the tax distribution language strictly pro rata so the amendment does not create a second class of stock and remember that it will not cover distributions already made. Do not amend an otherwise correct return merely to manufacture a different characterization for SBA purposes. If the SBA questions the distributions, a response should focus on three questions:
- Were the dollars distributed ordinary profits or traceable loan proceeds;
- Were the payments authorized by the governing documents; and
- Do they comply with the SBA’s own written description of normal course distributions?
Assuming the answers are positive, you should have a strong position on good facts. But remember, this is a negotiation, and it belongs with someone who handles administrative disputes.
For new engagements, add one question to the entity planning checklist: does the client have an outstanding SBA loan, and can the client provide the loan documents? If yes, ask the SBA servicing center for consent before the conversion. Keep in mind, silence is not consent and the paragraph above the borrower’s signature says no provision “will be waived without prior written consent of SBA.”
This does not mean the CPA was careless. Nobody asked to see the loan documents because nobody thought a disaster loan had covenants that limited an entity’s ability to change its structure. But this agreement does, and the owners who find out about these clauses at closing, or in a Chapter 11, will not be the only people in the room asking who dropped the ball.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Phillip Zagotti, JD, CPA, is an attorney and CPA at North Star Law Firm. His practice focuses on SBA loan defaults and settlements, tax controversy, bankruptcy, and estate and trust taxation. He is the coauthor of Taxed: A Taxpayer’s Guide to Tax Defense and Resolution and Trusted: The Essential Guide for Trustees. He can be reached at htx-legal.net.
Photo credit: Freepik
Sign in to get access to this free resource, and all of our whitepapers and reports.
Download this content today!
Register Now Already registered? Click here to Log In