How many small business clients have you quietly lost in the past year?
Most accounting firms don’t lose small business clients because of price. They lose them because those clients feel overlooked.
Small business owners are looking for a partner. They want someone who understands their business and helps them make better business decisions year-round, not just a tax return six months after the fact. But when firms stay stuck in a compliance-only model, small business clients often walk away, feeling like they’re on their own.
Fortunately, this creates a massive opportunity for firms willing to make strategic shifts in how they serve this market. Over the past 20+ years, I’ve worked exclusively with small businesses across a range of industries. I’ve seen where firms get it wrong, and more importantly, I’ve learned what it takes to get it right.
Recommended Articles
In this article, I’ll break down why the traditional model doesn’t work for small business clients, what they actually need from their accountant, and five practical shifts any firm can make to better serve this market and grow because of it.
Why Small Business Clients Leave Their Accountants
Recently, I had a conversation with a restaurant owner who’d just left his previous CPA.
“Matt, I paid my old accountant $5,000 to prepare my taxes,” he told me. “Then, in June, I got hit with a $30,000 tax bill I wasn’t expecting. When I called to ask why no one warned me, I was told, ‘You didn’t ask about tax planning. That’s a separate service.'”
This story isn’t unique. I hear versions of it constantly.
Small business owners don’t fire their accountants because of price. They fire them because they feel abandoned. They’re making critical business decisions in the dark, and their accountant only shows up once a year to tell them what they owed six months ago.
When your relationship with a client consists of “Send me your stuff in March, and I’ll file your return in April,” you’re not providing accounting services. In this scenario, you’re providing a commodity that can be replaced by anyone willing to charge $50 less.
Why Traditional Firms Struggle to Serve Small Businesses
Most accounting firms were built around a model that works beautifully for one thing: compliance.
You take information, you process it according to established rules, you produce a deliverable (tax return, audit report, compiled financial statement), and you move to the next client. It’s predictable, billable, and probably comfortable.
The problem is that compliance alone doesn’t solve the problems that keep small business owners awake at night.
They’re not lying awake worrying about whether their depreciation schedule is correct. They’re worried about:
- Making payroll next week
- Whether they’re pricing their services correctly
- If they should hire another employee or wait
- How much they’ll owe in taxes
- Whether their business is actually profitable
When you only offer compliance services, you’re answering questions no one’s asking while ignoring the questions that actually matter.
Every time a small business owner makes a major financial decision without your input, you’ve failed them. Not because you didn’t file their return correctly, but because you weren’t there when they actually needed you.
What Small Business Owners Need from Their Accountants
After working with hundreds of small business owners across restaurants, medical practices, service businesses, and franchises, I can tell you exactly what they need from their accountant:
They need a financial partner who helps them make better decisions in real-time.
And here’s what that actually looks like in practice:
- Monthly financial visibility: Clean, accurate books every month so they know where they stand before problems become crises
- Proactive tax planning: Quarterly projections and strategic conversations so they’re never surprised by their tax bill
- Honest feedback: Someone who’ll tell them when their labor costs are too high or when they’re pricing services incorrectly
- Industry expertise: An accountant who understands their specific business model and can benchmark their performance
- Responsive communication: Answers when they have questions, not just during tax season
Notice what’s missing from that list? “File my tax return.”
Don’t get me wrong, tax compliance absolutely matters. But it’s table stakes. The firms winning in the small business space are the ones that have figured out how to layer advisory services on top of solid compliance work.
What Firms Lose by Overlooking Small Businesses
Let’s talk about what you’re actually giving up when you stick to compliance-only relationships with small business clients.
The lifetime value of a small business client who stays with you for multiple years—paying for monthly accounting, payroll services, tax planning, and advisory support—far exceeds what you’ll ever make from annual tax returns alone.
When a client is paying you monthly for comprehensive services, you’re generating recurring revenue that compounds year after year. As their business grows, the scope of services typically expands, creating natural revenue growth within the relationship. Compare that to the one-time annual fee from tax-only work, where you’re essentially starting from zero every year trying to win back the same client.
When you’re actually helping clients grow their businesses, they refer other business owners to you. Our best marketing has always been word-of-mouth from clients who feel like we’re genuinely invested in their success.
The firms that crack this code build more valuable practices with recurring revenue, deeper client relationships, and significantly higher multiples when it’s time to sell.
Five Ways to Build a Better Firm for Small Business Clients
So how do you actually make this transition? Here are the five shifts that transformed my practice, and I’ve seen them work for other firms willing to make the change, as well.
Shift #1: From Annual Reporting to Monthly Financial Partnership
The old model: Client sends you a box of receipts in March. You organize it, file the return, send a bill.
The new model: You’re in their QuickBooks every month, reconciling accounts, catching errors, providing clean financial statements, and having regular conversations about what the numbers mean.
This shift is uncomfortable because it requires building systems and processes that don’t exist in most firms. But it’s also the foundation for everything else. You cannot provide meaningful advisory services based on annual data that’s months out of date.
Shift #2: From Reactive Compliance to Proactive Advisory
The old model: Client calls with a question. You answer it. Maybe you bill for it, maybe you don’t.
The new model: You’re proactively reaching out with observations, recommendations, and strategic guidance before they ask.
This means quarterly tax projection meetings, regular reviews of key metrics, and conversations about decisions before they’re made. It requires building advisory time into your pricing model so you’re not nickel-and-diming clients for every phone call.
Shift #3: From Hourly Billing to Fixed-Fee Value Pricing
The old model: Track every six-minute increment. Send unpredictable invoices that spike during busy season.
The new model: Quote a fixed monthly fee based on scope and value. Client knows exactly what they’ll pay. You’re incentivized to work efficiently.
I stopped billing by the hour 15 years ago, and it was the best business decision I ever made. It eliminated pricing conversations, improved cash flow predictability, and aligned our interests with our clients’ interests.
Shift #4: From Paper-Based to Technology-Enabled Service
The old model: Client drops off documents. You enter data manually. Errors happen. Everything takes longer than it should.
The new model: Direct bank feeds, integrated payroll systems, automated workflows, and real-time financial data.
Technology doesn’t replace the relationship. It frees you up to focus on the parts that actually require professional judgment. If you’re still manually entering transactions from bank statements, you’re competing with bookkeepers charging $30/hour, not providing CPA-level strategic value.
Shift #5: From Generalist to Industry-Specialized Expertise
The old model: You’ll work with anyone who needs a tax return filed.
The new model: You develop deep expertise in two to three industries where you can provide specialized guidance.
When I can tell a restaurant owner exactly where their food cost percentage should be or help a medical practice understand the financial implications of adding a new provider, that’s worth infinitely more than generic tax advice. Industry specialization lets you charge premium pricing because you’re solving specific problems that generalists can’t.
Why Most Firms Stay Stuck and What That Means for You
Believe it or not, most firms won’t make these shifts.
Why? Because change is hard. It requires investment in technology, training, and new processes. It means turning away clients who just want the cheapest tax return. It demands that you get comfortable having advisory conversations instead of just processing returns.
Many firm owners look at what I’m describing and think, “That sounds like way more work.”
And you know what? They’re right. It is more work.
But it’s also more profitable, more sustainable, and infinitely more rewarding. When clients call to thank you for helping them avoid a costly mistake, or when a business owner tells you that working with your firm was the best decision they made for their company, you remember why you became an accountant in the first place.
Firms willing to do this work will absolutely dominate the small business market for the next decade. Because the need is massive, the competition is still stuck in the old model, and business owners are desperate for someone who actually gets it.
Three Steps to Start Shifting Your Practice
If you’re reading this and thinking, “Ok, I see the opportunity, but where do I actually start?” here are three concrete steps you can take:
Step 1: Pick one industry to specialize in. Look at your current client base. Where do you already have three to five clients in the same industry? Start there. Learn everything you can about that industry’s financial benchmarks, common challenges, and growth patterns.
Step 2: Convert three compliance-only clients to monthly service agreements. Identify three small business clients you know need more help. Propose a monthly package that includes bookkeeping, monthly financials, and quarterly tax planning. Price it properly. Don’t undercharge because you’re nervous.
Step 3: Build your first advisory workflow. Create a simple quarterly tax projection process. Schedule 30-minute calls with those three clients. Review their year-to-date numbers, project their annual tax liability, and make recommendations. Do this consistently for 12 months.
These steps won’t transform your practice overnight. But they’ll prove the model works. You’ll see client retention improve. You’ll get referrals. And you’ll start to understand how much more valuable this approach is compared to compliance-only relationships.
The Opportunity to Serve Small Businesses Is Still Wide Open
Twenty-two years ago, I stumbled into small business accounting while looking for my next job. What I found was a wide-open market of business owners who needed more than just compliance. And I saw a profession that wasn’t showing up for them.
That opportunity hasn’t gone away. If anything, it’s grown.
Small business owners want a financial partner who understands their world and helps them make smarter decisions. They want someone who genuinely cares about their success. They’re willing to pay for that value. They just haven’t been able to find it.
You don’t need to overhaul your entire practice tomorrow. You can start small with a few clients. Build the systems and workflow one piece at a time. But start.
The longer you wait, the more opportunities pass you by. And the more business owners go without the guidance they truly need.
If this approach resonates with you, I’m always happy to connect with other professionals who are serious about serving small businesses better. Helping clients get one step better is what we do every day at my firm, and helping other firm owners do the same is something I care deeply about.
===
Matt Patrick, CPA, is the founder of Patrick Accounting, a Memphis-based firm specializing in small business accounting, tax, and advisory services. Since 2003, Patrick Accounting has worked exclusively with small and medium-sized business owners, helping them simplify their financial complexities and build thriving companies. Connect with Matt on LinkedIn or visit patrickaccounting.com.
Thanks for reading CPA Practice Advisor!
Subscribe Already registered? Log In
Need more information? Read the FAQs
