By Elizabeth Beastrom, President, Tax & Accounting Professionals, Thomson Reuters.
Here’s a sobering reality check for tax firm leaders: 79% of professionals believe AI will transform our industry within five years, yet only 14% of firms have developed actual AI strategies. The majority are confusing tool procurement with strategic planning—and it’s costing them dearly.
The latest Future of Professionals Report from Thomson Reuters reveals that firms with visible AI strategies are 3.1 times as likely to be experiencing at least one form of return on investment compared to firms without any significant plans for AI adoption. For the firms investing in software, the difference isn’t the technology they’re purchasing, it’s the strategic framework guiding their decisions.
Recommended Articles
Technology August 18, 2025
Experiences 2025 – Not So Secret AI Agents
The Tool Trap: Why Technology Alone Fails
Walk into most tax firms today, and you’ll find partners excited about the latest AI-powered tax software or document review platform. They’ve made the purchase, completed the implementation, and expected transformation to follow. Instead, they’re seeing modest efficiency gains at best, with 32% of firms reporting they’re moving too slowly with AI adoption.
The problem lies in the absence of strategy. Successful AI adoption requires a comprehensive approach that aligns technology investments with business objectives, operational realities, and human factors. The firms seeing transformational results are following a specific playbook that treats AI as a strategic business initiative, not a technology purchase.
The Six-Principle Framework That Delivers Results
After analyzing data from 462 tax professionals across 25 countries, Thomson Reuters has identified six core principles that separate AI leaders from laggards:
1. Align AI Strategy with Business Goals
Leading firms don’t start with AI—they start with identifying business challenges. If your primary goal is revenue growth, your AI strategy should focus on advisory service expansion through intelligent client data analysis. If operational efficiency is the priority, target workflow automation and intelligent document processing.
For example, rather than generic AI implementation, successful firms set specific objectives like “reduce tax preparation time by 30% through AI-assisted data extraction” or “increase advisory revenue per client by 25% through AI-powered opportunity identification.”
2. Select Strategic Technology Partners
The evaluation process goes far beyond feature comparisons. Strategic firms assess partners on their ability to support long-term transformation, not just immediate needs. This means evaluating implementation support, ongoing training programs, integration capabilities, and the partner’s roadmap for advancing AI capabilities alongside your firm’s growth.
3. Prioritize High-Impact Pilot Projects
Rather than firm-wide rollouts, successful implementations begin with two to three carefully selected pilot projects that demonstrate clear value. These pilots serve multiple purposes: they build internal momentum, provide learning opportunities, and generate case studies that accelerate broader adoption.
4. Establish Governance and Ethical Frameworks
Before the first AI tool goes live, leading firms develop clear policies around data privacy, security, and responsible AI use. This includes defining processes for verifying AI outputs, especially critical when using generative AI for client-facing work. The governance framework becomes the foundation for scaling AI usage safely across the organization.
5. Invest in Talent Development
AI is a tool, but people drive its success. Strategic firms invest in training that goes beyond button-pushing to develop the professional judgment necessary for reviewing AI outputs critically. Our research shows professionals build AI proficiency most effectively through multiple learning methods: experimentation, peer-to-peer learning, and formal training.
6. Measure, Iterate, and Adapt
Leading firms define key performance indicators upfront and track progress religiously. This isn’t just about ROI. It includes time savings, error-reduction rates, client satisfaction scores, and employee engagement metrics. Regular assessment allows for course corrections and ensures AI initiatives remain aligned with evolving business needs.
The Five-Criteria Evaluation Framework
Once you’ve established your framework, the next challenge becomes selecting the right technology partners to execute your vision. This is where many firms stumble—they either get overwhelmed by vendor promises or make decisions based on features rather than best fit.
The most successful firms approach technology evaluation systematically, using five core criteria to assess whether any AI solution will advance their strategic objectives:
- Functionality and Accuracy: Does the solution address specific business goals? Can it scale with increasing client volumes? What are the documented accuracy rates and built-in verification mechanisms?
- Security and Compliance: The solution must meet SOC 2 compliance standards, offer appropriate encryption protocols, and align with regulations like GDPR and CCPA. Role-based permissions should align with existing governance requirements.
- Implementation and Integration: How quickly can you expect results? Does the solution integrate with existing systems without extensive reformatting? What level of implementation support and training is provided?
- Usability and Adoption: The interface must be intuitive enough for widespread adoption. Can the solution be customized to match firm-specific workflows and terminology?
- Practice Alignment and Workflow Fit: How well does the technology support day-to-day operations, including document formats, approval cycles, and collaboration requirements?
From Framework to Implementation: Strategic Use Case Mapping
Having the right evaluation framework is essential, but successful firms take one more critical step: they map specific AI applications to their primary business objectives before making any technology investments. This strategic alignment ensures that every AI initiative serves a clear purpose and contributes measurably to firm goals.
Rather than implementing AI tools in isolation, leading firms systematically connect technology capabilities to business outcomes:
For revenue growth, they implement AI-powered advisory service expansion, using intelligent systems to analyze client data and surface relevant strategies automatically. This enables the transition from compliance-focused to higher-value advisory relationships.
For operational efficiency, they deploy intelligent document analysis for contract review and AI-powered audit sampling optimization that determines optimal sample sizes based on client risk profiles.
For talent retention, they use AI to handle routine tasks like data entry and basic reconciliations, freeing professionals for higher-value work while implementing AI-powered knowledge assistance that reduces bottlenecks for junior staff.
And for client experience enhancement, they create real-time client dashboards with AI-generated insights and personalized regulatory updates that demonstrate ongoing value beyond compliance work.
The Competitive Reality
Our projections show innovator firms could unlock up to $52,000 in value per professional within 12 months, while firms without AI strategies will struggle with talent attraction and retention. This isn’t theoretical; 88% of innovator firms are expected to have comprehensive AI strategies within a year, compared to just 10% of laggard firms.
Moving Beyond the Tool Trap
The message is clear: buying AI tools without a strategic framework is like purchasing a flashy sports car without learning to drive. The technology has tremendous potential, but realizing that potential requires thoughtful planning, systematic implementation, and ongoing refinement.
The firms that understand this distinction—treating AI as a business initiative rather than a technology procurement exercise—are already pulling ahead. They’re seeing not just efficiency gains, but fundamental improvements in service delivery, client relationships, and competitive positioning.
The question isn’t which AI tools to buy—it’s whether you have the plans in place to make them successful. That’s the essential foundation for true ROI on your firm’s AI investments.
Thanks for reading CPA Practice Advisor!
Subscribe Already registered? Log In
Need more information? Read the FAQs
