Skip to main content


PenSoft — Payroll Accounting Edition



PenSoft offers several payroll processing and employee management systems geared toward use directly by small and mid-sized businesses as well as a version tailored to the needs of professionals managing the payrolls of several employers. The Accounting Edition includes all of the features found in the vendor’s comprehensive payroll systems, including benefits management, unlimited deductions, job costing, departmental management, consolidated reporting and timesheet management. It also offers client management functions for invoicing, batch processing, global settings and firm management tools. For this review, the Accounting Edition fits our “Wholesale Payroll Professional” model, offering support for large client and employee bases that may be dispersed over several states, with tools for the professional firm to control all aspects of processing and managing all compliance reporting and payment functions.


PenSoft opens into a work environment that offers traditional pull-down menus across the top of the screen for general system functions, such as file management, program setup, activities, reports, utilities and Help, while the core payroll processing and management functions of the program are available via text/button links for company functions, employee management, payroll processing, deposits, checkwriting, reporting, export and data backups. During company and employee setup, the system offers tabbed interfaces with some guidance for ensuring that at least basic data is entered, along with the ability to use companies or employees as templates and to make global changes across all employees and companies. Employee information screens offer departmental and project-based assignments for job costing functions, as well as good customization and the ability to track multiple employee types, any kind of employee and income types, unlimited deductions, retirement plans, unemployment, workers’ comp, leave accruals, multi-state taxes, training and education, and other HR-oriented data. PenSoft includes built-in support for the New Hire Act and includes required reporting, as well.

After setup, the system is fairly simple to use, with a client/employer selection list that provides limited sort and filter functions with no options for viewing data such as pending runs or due dates for multiple employers without using the reporting functions. Otherwise, the system provides good multi-client management functions, including invoicing with client letter templates and the ability to process payrolls for any number of employers with any number of employees. PenSoft Payroll can also support any number of concurrent users, with tools for preventing data overwrite.

The Accounting Edition includes payroll tax tables and forms preparation for federal and all states, including new hire reports, but it does not provide compliance for municipalities with payroll tax reporting requirements. It does, however, provide tools for distributing income for employees with multiple state taxation. Integrated direct deposit and pay-to-debit card is available as an add-on through partnership with Intercept EFT. The program does not offer batch processing of payrolls across multiple employer entities, but some multi-client management functions are available via overview screens and batch reporting functions. 4.25


Due date tracking and calendaring functions are limited and do not offer multi-client views of pending activities, and there are no tools for alerts or reminders. The program includes preparation for all quarterly wage and employment reporting for federal and all states, with the ability to print signature-ready fileable forms. Or an add-on service allows users to electronically file the 940 series to the IRS through PenSoft. The program does not have built-in utilities for e-filing to states or remitting EFT payments to taxing entities. A broad array of managerial reports include wage, departmental, job costing, GL, deductions, liabilities and other options, with limited customization options through the built-in report writer, but no output for common formats. Employee management screens provide very detailed overviews, with the ability to set defaults, access reports and quickly move to individual histories and withholding data. 3.75


PenSoft Payroll Accounting Edition integrates with the optional payroll services available from PenSoft, such as direct deposit and e-filing. It can import employee data and timecard information from common file formats, including time clock systems, and can export payroll data into formats importable by most accounting programs. The add-on Employee Tracker module offers more comprehensive employee management functions, timesheet management and productivity analyses. 4.5


Assistive features in the program include a traditional Help utility, with many work screens offering Help buttons that go directly to information related to the active process (such as running payroll). It also offers links to online resources. PenSoft’s support website includes an online knowledgebase, downloadable tax forms, calculators and an online user forum. Program and rate table updates are available for download or by CD on a quarterly basis, with no automatic download utility offered. Unlimited online, email and phone-based live support is included in pricing. 4.25


Although PenSoft Payroll Accounting Edition is a locally installed, on-premise program, options are available for web-based collaboration with clients. This includes the add-on Remote Client utility, which lets users extend some program functions to clients, such as the ability to edit employee time and leave information. The TimeOnline add-on provides similar functions to client employees, providing a web-based time and attendance tracking system that routes data into the payroll program. Both of these systems are for data entry, with no options for sharing reports or pay stubs. Despite its limited functionality in this area, PenSoft Payroll Accounting Edition did not receiving a rating in this section because this category was identified as an attribute for web-based SaaS products for the purposes of this review. N/A


PenSoft Payroll Accounting Edition has strong multi-employer processing functions that are designed for firms managing virtually any number of clients and large employee bases, along with personnel and benefits management capabilities and some remote client access options. Pricing for the full professional system, which can be used to manage any number of employers and employees and any number of payroll runs, is $1,629. Direct deposit, e-filing and online client data-entry functions are available as add-ons.

2010 Overall Rating 4.25

See inside September 2010

Intuit — Intuit Online Payroll

7588 800-365-9618 The Intuit Online Payroll offering, formerly known as PayCycle, is one of several payroll products and services offered by Intuit. The completely web-based system includes versions for small businesses and for accounting professionals managing payroll activities and compliance for multiple employers, with automated compliance reporting, payments and due date alerts. The system […]


CCH Small Firm Services — ATX Payroll & TaxWise Payroll

7297 866-345-4171 CCH Small Firm Services is the technology company behind the ATX and TaxWise professional tax compliance suites, which are popular with small and mid-sized practices. Under each of these brands, the vendor also offers collections of professional accounting and client service applications, including trial balance, write-up, asset management, client bookkeeping, and separate […]