Skip to main content

Sales Tax

Are Your Clients Likely to Face a SALT Audit?

Historically, a business' gross revenues follow seasonal patterns and even a small change in gross revenue should result in a small change in the associated accounts. In an attempt to discover why one established contractor was selected for audit, I reviewed their sales tax filings and created the below table.

sales-tax-jurisdictions1_11675389

Are you or your clients risk averse and totally rational?

  • “This high profile, attention-grabbing color is not an issue for me;”
  • “I wear my seatbelt, drive slightly under the posted limit and never text.”
  • “As a reasonable person I know that every deviation from the norm invites a moving violation.”
  • “Law enforcement personnel like sales tax auditors look for things outside the norm, those red flags indicate non-compliance.”

Historically, a business' gross revenues follow seasonal patterns and even a small change in gross revenue should result in a small change in the associated accounts. In an attempt to discover why one established contractor was selected for audit, I reviewed their sales tax filings and created the below table.

The exact dollar amounts are not as important as the relationships between them. The chart illustrates two of the many red flags contained in this data set.  How many red flags can you find?

 

Gross Sales

Use Taxable

Q1 2011

330,172

1,968,518

Q2 2011

335,540

1,324,887

Q3 2011

768,663

2,450,371

Q4 2011

1,904,788

2,724,815

 

 

 

Q1 2012

11,994,786

2,420,044

Q2 2012

14,760,647

0

Q3 2012

18,557,313

0

Q4 2012

15,797,641

0

Red Flags

1.     2011 use taxable purchases exceed gross sales by a million dollars each quarter.  Established businesses normally have some use tax but not 2 ½ times greater than revenues.

  • Could the accounts be backwards or the contractor be reporting labor sales as gross revenue and materials as use taxable purchases, thus understating gross sales?

2.     Revenues double between Q2 & Q3 – 2011, again between Q3 & Q4 – 2011 and a 5 fold     increase between Q4 – 2011 & Q1 – 2012, growth the stabilizes at over 10 times prior quarters.

  • The doubling of revenues Q2 &Q3 2011 is possible.  Note- as revenues doubled use tax doubled.
  • Q4 – 2011 to Q1 – 2012 5x increase – hard to believe.  Note – use taxable amount stabilizes, why?
  • Q1 – 2012 gross sales stabilize   Note- lack of use taxable purchases in remaining quarters.  That seems unlikely given prior period reporting.

Attracting Attention

States use many sophisticated techniques to identify and target non-compliant companies, such as:

  • Erratic ratios of sales to use tax,
  • Rapid growth,
  • Zero returns
  • Large increase of sales

Data, while important is still reported by a person.  Based on the above red flags the following questions should be asked.

  • Did key personnel leave?
  • Was 5x growth delayed billing or prior period underreporting due to staffing issues?
  • Does the entity need hands on training and coaching?
  • Should I visit the entity and observe their operations?

————–

September SALT Checklist

  • Analyze your clients for tax audit red flags (see related article)
  • Examine client internal controls relating to state and local tax issues and for future protection from audits
  • Filings – in addition to current tax obligations, help clients get up-to-date on delinquent tax filings
  • Reporting – review clients' year-to-date SALT expense and liabilities for accuracy
  • Planning – estimate and schedule all state and local tax filings that will be due in Q4
  • Legislation – recent legislation has affected taxes in Illinois, Utah, and California. Make sure you're up-to-date on SALT-related legislation in all states where you have clients

—————–

Eide Bailly is a top 25 CPA firm with 24 offices in 11 statesEide Bailly's National Tax Office serves as a resource for clients to help analyze complex tax issues related to business decisions. Our professionals are committed to helping clients stay informed about tax news, developments and trends through various specialty areas, including cost segregation studies, wealth transfer, state and local taxation, international tax, IRS controversy and procedures, tax-exempt organizations and tax legislation. For additional information visit www.eidebailly.com

See inside September 2014

How to Hone Your Soft Skills to Strengthen Client Relationships

As summer draws to a close, kids and young students aren’t the only ones who need to think about heading back to school. Your employees — even your top performers — can become stronger contributors by enhancing their abilities and expertise through professional development opportunities.

Previous

40 Leaders Who Are Shaping the Profession of Tomorrow

Each year, the 40 Under 40 program seeks to honor a diverse array of professionals who are helping to shape the profession they work in. How does one shape a profession? For these unique professionals, that question is answered in a variety of ways. For some, this is achieved through ardent support for and evangelizing […]

Next