2013 Review of Traditional Tax Preparation Systems: Traditional Workflow

From the May 2013 issue.

In our May issue each year, we review tax preparation systems designed for professionals who prepare federal and state income tax returns for individuals, businesses and other entities.

There is a significant difference between the types of professional preparation systems on the market, but differences in capabilities are often intentional, as the software developers design their programs for use by different types of firms. That said, it wouldn't really be appropriate to compare a system designed for smaller, 1040-focused firms, to a system that might be used by top 100 tax and accounting practices with offices and clients across the country.

Therefore, we divide the tax systems into two categories based on how firms operate: Traditional Workflow and Advanced Workflow. This review section looks at those that we believe are designed for tax practices with a Traditional Workflow. Our review of Advanced Workflow systems is at www.cpapracticeadvisor.com/10911022.

2013 Reviews of Professional
Tax Preparation Systems -
Traditional Workflow

CPA Practice Advisor reviewed six professional
tax preparation systems that fit into the
"Traditional Workflow" category.
Follow the links below to see how they compared.


For clarification, here is how we define these categories:

Traditional Workflow – Defined
In firms with a “traditional workflow,” nearly all of a tax engagement is handled by a single preparer, although there may be an administrative person at the front end (scanning, handling primary basic data entry, etc) and a manager/partner reviewing the return at the end of the engagement. The primary preparer guides all client communication, information gathering, data input, and processing. This typically takes place in a single interview with the client, and is the most typical firm workflow method for high volume 1040 practices with anywhere from one to 10 or more staff.

Advanced Workflow – Defined
Firms with an “advanced workflow” often have clients that require several staff to work on a series of federal and state returns. Firms who use these applications typically have administrative personnel or paraprofessionals performing data entry and organizational tasks, and reserve professional staff for more technical tax issues associated with the return. These firms typically require all returns and supporting documents to be reviewed by at least one person at a level above the preparer. Advanced workflow tax systems support the simplest of 1040s through business entities with complex ownership structures, multi-state apportionment of income, oil & gas partnerships, cross-border or expatriate returns, or elections for special treatment of transactions.

The Traditional Workflow tax preparation systems reviewed here meet the needs of a wide range of different preparers, from recently trained volunteers at an IRS VITA site all the way to large firms who do not need the overhead or complexity associated with the more advanced products. These applications are designed to meet the everyday needs of the practitioner without being designed to address every niche practice area at lower price point.

While many readers may not want to even think about tax software after the challenges many firms faced this tax season (which included software reliability issues, delayed e-file acceptance, and some state calculation issues), May is still the best time of the year to switch tax software. Software vendors are ready to make deals with deep discounts, and users have time to learn the software with extended returns over the summer before the crunch of the next winter busy season. Two popular packages included in last year’s review, RedGear’s TaxWorks and CCH Small Firm Services’ ATX, declined to participate.

The tax application is only one part of the process of preparing a return, and users should consider many other features when purchasing the tax application. We reviewed Tax Document Automation systems in our January 2013 digital issue (bit.ly/taxdoc13), which are being used successfully by many practitioners. We will review many of the Document Storage Systems which have integrations with tax applications later this year. Many applications have support for importing balances and securities trades from small business accounting software or Microsoft Excel spreadsheets.

True web-based tax software has taken over the consumer-prepared return market (e.g. TurboTax, TaxAct, and others), but the full-time practitioner market is still using applications which are installed on a local computer. Although we believe that cloud-based tax applications will play a significant role in the future, the integrations in the current versions of these applications are still very limited. Many of the existing on-premises applications have plans to launch hosted or web-based versions of their software, and it is clear that there will be many innovations in this space over the next year.

Click here to view our 2013 reviews of Advanced Workflow systems.